Mobile Network Comparison

The Nokia Lumia 800 is the latest Windows Mobile 7 smartphone. It comes with the revolutionary and simple live tiles interface, free Nokia sat nav software, a clear OLED screen and a top notch camera.

However, with rising tariffs rates and astonishing up-front prices for high-end phones it is increasingly hard to get a modern smartphone. Having the cash in hand for a brand new iPhone 4S is hard enough but falling into a 24 month contract can really put a dent in your budget. And that’s not even considering the masses of small print, overage charges and extras that get people like you paying even more money than you signed up for.

To make things worse about mobile phone contracts, Orange just increased their rates by 4.35% even if you’re already in the middle of a contract. This is clearly a real bummer, so today we’re going to look at how to save yourself some bucks with the new Nokia Lumia 800.

Orange

We want to look only at the contract deals which give you the phone for free. The one we found with the Nokia Lumia 800 free on Orange is currently £36 monthly. Included in this is:

• 600 minutes
• Unlimited texts
• 1GB mobile internet

Of course, the actually price you’ll pay after the Orange price increase is £37.56 a month. This equates to an additional £37 over the 24 month contract.

That makes a total of £901.44! Surely there must be better deals that don’t cost nearly a grand for 2 years use?

Vodafone

Another contract deal that includes the Nokia Lumia 800 free is from Vodafone on a similarly priced offer:

• 900 minutes
• Unlimited texts
• 750MB mobile internet

This costs £36 a month for 2 years which works at at £1.56 less per month compared to Orange’s deal after January 8th. You also get an extra 300 minutes. The only sacrifice is a loss of 250MB of data, but if you prefer call time over internet use then this maybe for you. The total cost is £864 over the whole 24 month contract. ⇒ Get this deal now ⇐

3

Probably the best contract deal for the Nokia Lumia 800 is from 3. There you can get the phone for free on a low-priced £30/month tariff. This includes:

• 500 minutes
• 5000 texts
• 1GB mobile internet

This offers a great balance between calls and texts and, importantly, offers a full 1GB of included mobile data. The total over the whole two year contract is only £720. ⇒ Get this deal now ⇐.

However, this is in a contract so who knows what could be hiding in the small print especially as they could follow Orange and increase prices by up to 5.4%. Also, you should be aware of extra charges – for example, if you typically used 1GB of data on a smartphone like this, you might face huge additional charges after exceeding your 750MB limit.

Giffgaff

Contracts can offer great value but they are not for everybody. If you want to steer clear of a contract but still get a great phone like the Nokia Lumia 800, you can go SIM free. This is the budget option but, if you don’t need lots of minutes, it can work out great.

The phone currently costs only £429.99 from Amazon with free delivery. Then you need to order a free micro-SIM from PAYG network Giffgaff (this is because the Nokia Lumia 800 can’t take normal-sized SIM cards.

Then look at Giffgaff’s great value goodybags – their rolling monthly tariffs. If you want a budget option, their £10 goodybag will give you:

• 900 minutes
• Unlimited texts
• Unlimited mobile internet

For £10/month, truly unlimited internet is astounding as you are likely to be able to use data at your hearts content. it’s the perfect match for a data-hungry phone like the Lumia 800. If you chose this method there is less call time per month, but if you are going to be spending this much money on a new smart phone it’s likely that data usage will play a very important roll in your new mobile’s life. What’s more, Giffgaff call charges are very low and all your calls to other Giffgaff mobiles are completely free all the time.

So for £429.99, plus a £10 goodybag for 24 months comes to £670 – that’s over £200 cheaper than Orange’s deal!

A pricer alternative is the £20 goodybag which offers:

• 800 minutes
• Unlimited texts
• Unlimited mobile internet

Once again, you have to buy the phone in advance from Amazon then order the £20 goodybag. This comes to a total cost of ownership over two years of £910 but if you want to make use of the unlimited data it’s definitely worth it. You also won’t have to worry about going over your limits and having to pay overage charges. So if you don’t want a contract, its possible to get a great deal by going SIM free and choosing a PAYG network instead.

Summary

The above graph should show you what the various options are and, as it has calculations for total cost of ownership, makes it clear which deal would be cheapest for you.

Those on Giffgaff have been given the chance to earn a very merry Christmas this year – it’s their fourth ever Payback payout just in time for last-minute present buying.

Giffgaff are partially run by their members and reward them for helping out. Payback is the system whereby customers have the opportunity to earn money by helping out in the community, and recruiting others to join. Then, every six months, users have the option to take their payback as airtime credit, donate it to a charity chosen by the community, or even have it as cash straight into their PayPal account!

From the day Giffgaff started, it was always about the community – they have a very friendly atmosphere over at the website forums and are always willing to hear new ideas to improve services. Two years in, “the mobile network run by you” is still generous as ever, paying out almost £1 million to the helpful community members this year, with one user earning nearly £14,000 this Christmas!

Over three thousand generous members chose to donate their payback to charity, earning £4,854 for Macmillian Cancer Support, which Giffgaff have matched, totalling £9,708! They have also made donations every other payback but December’s donation is almost double the amount donated in May 2010, and around seven times the amount donated from the first payback.

Without their dedicated customers, Giffgaff definitely wouldn’t be what it is today, and this is their way of saying thanks.

Where will Giffgaff go next? What new business ideas will be brought into play? Wherever it goes, the loyal Giffgaff community will be there, growing every day.

The iPhone 4S hit the shops a couple of months ago and it’s the perfect Christmas present with its a new dual-core 1GHz A5 processor, Siri and the massively upgraded camera. Last week we took a look at the best deals available for the low-end 16GB version but today we’ve analysed more than 100 tariff options and rounded up the very best deals on the 32GB model.

Total cost of ownership

As we explained last time, the best way to compare prices across networks and between contracts and PAYG is by calculating the Total cost of ownership. This is simply the overall amount you’ll have to pay for your new iPhone 4S and can be found by adding the initial cost of the handset to the monthly price of the plan multiplied by the length of the contract (in months). Or, if you speak maths:

Total cost of ownership = cost_handset + cost_{monthly tariff} × t_{contract length}

Going SIM-free involves a large upfront payment followed by a far cheaper PAYG tariff while, conversely, contracts usually have subsidised (or even free) handsets with pricier charges over the following months. Because it accounts for both factors, looking at total cost of ownership is the best way to compare the available options.

For example, imagine you want to buy a 32GB iPhone 4S with a plan that includes at least 300 minutes and you’ve narrowed your choice of network down to just O₂, Giffgaff and 3 as your main options. The cheapest deals available from each are as follows:

O₂ – £270 upfront then £29/month for 300 minutes, unlimited texts and 100MB data.
giffgaff – £599 upfront then £15/month for 400 minutes, unlimited texts and unlimited data.
Three – £219 upfront then £30/month for 300 minutes, 5000 texts and 500MB data.

If we compare these from a total cost of ownership point of view, it’s immediately obvious which choice is best.

The O₂ plan costs £270 for the phone but then you must pay £29/month for a 24 month contract which adds up to another £696. The total you have to pay over two years is a pricey £966.

The tariff on Giffgaff is a bit better as although you must splash out a huge £599 for the phone, you only pay £360 over the 24 month contract making a total of £959. And for your money you get 400 minutes instead of 300 as well as unlimited data and unlimited texts.

However, 3 turns out to be the best deal in this example. The iPhone 4S 32GB handset will only set you back £219 and then, even paying £30/month your total over two years is just £939 which beats both O₂ and Giffgaff.

iPhone 4S 32GB price comparison

In this comparison we’ve looked at all the deals available for the iPhone 4S 32GB version from the major UK networks (O₂, 3, Orange, T-Mobile and Vodafone) as well as the cheapest PAYG alternative from Giffgaff using their incredible value goodybags. We’ve also broken it down into separate sections for inclusive minutes, texts and data so you can see which deal is best for you. Don’t forget to also keep in mind the coverage in your area for the network you want to go with – our network coverage maps will let you know how good the signal strength is.

Best iPhone 4S 32GB deal by minutes

At least 200 minutes

If, however, you only need as little as 200 minutes a month, Giffgaff is the obvious winner being much much cheaper than the alternatives with a total cost of ownership of just £839 over two years.

You just need to order your £599 iPhone 4S 32GB then request a Giffgaff micro-SIM with £5 free credit. Next, log in to your account and buy the £10/month goodybag. This gives you 250 minutes, unlimited texts and unlimited data every month.

At least 300 minutes

If however you need 300 minutes a month, 3‘s offering is the best. The total is only £939 for a 24 month contract.

The offer is for a 32GB iPhone 4S with 300 minutes, 5000 texts and 500MB data for an initial cost of only £219 then £30/month. ⇒ Get this deal now ⇐.

At least 400 minutes

For 400 minutes a month, Giffgaff charges back into the lead with a price of only £959 in total.

Again, you have to buy your £599 iPhone 4S 32GB then order a Giffgaff micro-SIM with £5 free credit. Next, simply get the £15/month goodybag for 400 minutes, unlimited texts and unlimited data every month.

At least 500 minutes

3 has the easily best offer for a 500 minute contract with a total cost of ownership of £979.

For your money not only do you get the iPhone 4S 32GB but you also get 500 minutes, 5000 texts and 1GB data. The one-off cost is £139 for the phone and the monthly fee is £35/month. ⇒ Get this deal now ⇐.

At least 600 minutes

Finally, if you’re more talkative and you want to have 600 minutes every month, O₂ is the best choice for you with a total cost over 24 months of £1016.

The phone is only £200 then you have to pay £34/month for 600 minutes, 100MB data and unlimited texts. ⇒ Get this deal now ⇐.

3‘s tariff follows closely behind with a total of just £1029 (£13 more over 2 years). Arguably, it’s actually a much better deal due to the huge monthly allowances you get.

The price of the 32GB iPhone 4S handset is £189 but for your £35/month you get the incredible One Plan. This affords you a huge 2000 any-network minutes, 5000 3-to-3 minutes, 5000 texts and completely unlimited all-you-can-eat data. ⇒ Get this deal now ⇐.

Best iPhone 4S 32GB deal by texts

100-5000 texts

No matter whether you need only 100 texts, 5000 texts or even unlimited texts, the graph clearly shows that Giffgaff is your best bet with a total cost of ownership of just £839 over two years.

First just buy your 32GB iPhone 4S for an initial cost of £599 then order a free Giffgaff micro-SIM with £5 free credit. You can then get the £10/month goodybag that will give you 250 any-network minutes every month as well as unlimited texts and unlimited data.

An alternative for 100-500 texts

For 500 texts a month or less, O₂ also offer some very competitive deals. For example, if you want a 500 text allowance you can get an iPhone 4S 32GB for a total cost of ownership of just £844.

O₂ will give you your iPhone with 100 minutes, 500 texts and 100MB data for a one-off cost of £400 followed by a low-priced £18.50 monthly tariff. ⇒ Get this deal now ⇐.

Best iPhone 4S 32GB deal by data

100MB-unlimited data

Again, no matter how much mobile internet you use, Giffgaff are clearly the cheapest deal for an iPhone 4S 32GB at only £839 for 24 months which works out to total cost of only about £30/month including buying the phone.

Simply order your £599 iPhone 4S 32GB then request a Giffgaff micro-SIM with £5 free credit. Once it’s activated you just need to buy the £10/month goodybag that will give you unlimited data every month. You also get 250 minutes every month and unlimited texts.

An alternative for 100MB data

If you only need as little as 100MB data, O₂ also have a decent offer with an iPhone 4S for a total cost of only £844.

You get the phone as well as 100 minutes, 500 texts and 100MB data for a one-off cost of £400 followed by £18.50/month. ⇒ Get this deal now ⇐.

Summary

Once again, Giffgaff have come out as easily the best deal for buying the newest iPhone with some massive savings compared to other networks when you look at total cost of ownership. That is as long as you can find an unlocked SIM-free iPhone 4S in stock, of course!

O₂‘s iPhone 4S packages are a great budget option. While they aren’t quite as cheap as Giffgaff’s and the monthly allowances are much lower, they are often much more competitive than the high-street competition. However, do be aware of their high price for anything more than 100MB data and check their coverage in your area before buying though.

Finally, an honourable mention must go to 3’s iPhone 4S on the fantastic One Plan . This is an amazing offer for mobile-addicts with 7000 minutes to 3 mobiles and other networks, 5000 texts and truly unlimited data. 3 is also a great choice as they have easily the best 3G network in the country so you can always stay connected to a mobile internet connection. Check out their UK coverage maps to see for yourself.

That’s it again. Just like with the iPhone 4S 16GB version, there are plenty of incredible deals regardless of your need for minutes, texts or mobile data – you just need to look through all the options available which is exactly we did for you 🙂 Our look at all the iPhone 4S 64GB tariffs is coming up soon.